The FOID system required any Illinois resident who wanted to possess a firearm or ammunition to first obtain a state-issued identification card from the Illinois State Police. No other state had anything quite like it. You couldn't legally own so much as a box of .22 shells without a card in your wallet.

That last sentence is the one that lands. A box of .22s. Not a handgun, not an AR — a brick of rimfire. If you've ever grabbed a few hundred rounds off the shelf without thinking twice, that's the baseline freedom Illinois residents don't have. Every FOID story I've heard from Illinois shooters eventually involves a delay, an expiration, or a bureaucratic gap at exactly the wrong time.

In practice, the system worked inconsistently — FOID cards were revoked slowly or not at all when cardholders became prohibited persons, a problem that would generate headlines decades later when mass shooters were found to have had their FOID cards revoked but their weapons not confiscated.

This is the part that should bother everyone regardless of where you stand on the broader debate. You built the whole system around a card, and then the card didn't get pulled when it was supposed to. That's not a civil liberties argument — that's just a broken administrative process. When the one mechanism you built to keep guns out of prohibited hands has a known failure mode and nobody fixes it for decades, it undermines every argument made in its favor.

Illinois sat at the center of American firearms history in ways that are easy to underestimate. The state gave the country some of its most restrictive gun laws and some of its most commercially significant handgun manufacturers — sometimes within fifty miles of each other.

Rock Island is still running. That's not a footnote — that's a federal arsenal that's been producing military hardware since before the Civil War, sitting in the same state that banned new handgun registrations in Chicago in 1982. The split isn't new, and it isn't going away.

For those of you who've lived in or shot through Illinois — either as residents or passing through on a road trip with a firearm in the car — what was your actual experience navigating the FOID system or the carry laws, and did it change how you thought about reciprocity when you got back to Idaho?

Read the full article in The Handbook → | By The Boise Gun Club Team