Submit a Firearm Review
Share your hands-on experience with the shooting community. Rate firearms across five categories using our Gunmetacritic-style system. Earn 50 brass when your review is approved.
01 // FORM
Submit Your Review
fill out the form below to add your Gunmetacritic review
02 // GUIDELINES
Review Guidelines
what makes a great review
Hands-On Experience
Review firearms you actually own or have shot extensively. First-hand experience required.
Honest Ratings
Rate accuracy, reliability, ergonomics, build quality, and value honestly. Your scores help others decide.
Detailed Feedback
Share specific pros and cons. What works well? What could be better? Help the community make informed decisions.
How Our Letter Grade System Works
Exceptional
Good
Average
Below Average
Your overall letter grade is calculated automatically from the average of your five category scores. We use half-letter grades (A+, A, A-, etc.) for precision.
03 // CATEGORIES
Understanding Category Scores
what each rating measures
Accuracy (0-100)
How accurately does it shoot? Consider grouping, consistency, and inherent accuracy.
- Grouping at various distances
- Barrel quality and rifling
- Sight quality (iron or optics-ready)
Reliability (0-100)
Does it go bang every time? Consider malfunctions, cycling, and durability.
- Feed/extraction issues
- Ammo compatibility
- Performance over time
Ergonomics (0-100)
How does it feel in hand? Consider grip, controls, trigger, and recoil.
- Grip texture and comfort
- Controls placement and reach
- Trigger feel and reset
Build Quality (0-100)
How well is it made? Consider fit/finish, materials, and attention to detail.
- Machining and tolerances
- Material quality
- Finish and coating durability
Value (0-100)
Is it worth the price? Consider performance per dollar and competitive alternatives.
- Price vs. performance
- Features for the money
- Resale value and market demand