Article Info
CT's Gun Ban History Challenged
| Scope | |
|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | Federal |
| Impact | national |
| Key Entities | |
| Second Amendment attorney, won Wolford v. Lopez at SCOTUS | Alan Beck |
| Defendant defending its AR-15/assault weapons ban | State of Connecticut |
| Court considering the AR-15 ban case | Supreme Court of the United States |
| Litigating related 2A cases on gun-free zones and carry permit fees | Department of Justice |
| Legal Issues | |
| |
| What It Means | |
| |
| Timeline | |
| November 1, 2025 | Podcast critique of Connecticut's SCOTUS brief published |
| Related Laws | |
CT's Gun Ban History Challenged
2A lawyer Alan Beck says Connecticut's Supreme Court brief twists medieval English law to defend its AR-15 ban
From The Boise Gun Club Handbook
Alan Beck, the attorney who just won Wolford v. Lopez at the Supreme Court, says Connecticut is misreading 500-year-old English law to prop up its "assault weapons" ban before the justices.
State of play: Connecticut's defense of its AR-15 ban leans heavily on historical analogues — a requirement under the Court's Bruen test, which demands modern gun laws match the "how" and "why" of regulations that existed at the founding or in the broader Anglo-American tradition. The state's brief cites a string of medieval English restrictions on weapons like lancegays, steelets, and handguns as proof that total bans on specific weapon types have deep historical roots.
Beck, speaking on The Reload's podcast, says that's not what those laws actually did.
The legal problem: Beck walked through the cited statutes and found most weren't bans on owning or making the weapons at all.
- Carry restrictions, not possession bans: Several of the laws Connecticut cites only restricted where a person could carry certain weapons, not whether they could own them.
- Anti-poaching rules: Others were aimed at keeping commoners from hunting the king's game, not at public safety or crime control — a very different "why" than a modern assault weapons ban.
Between the lines: That distinction matters under Bruen because the test isn't satisfied just by finding an old law that mentions a similar weapon. The government has to show the historical law and the modern one impose a comparable burden for a comparable reason. If Connecticut's analogues were really carry bans or poaching statutes, they don't do the work the state needs them to do to justify banning possession of an entire class of rifles.
Beck argued the brief is misleading on both fronts — what the old laws restricted and why lawmakers passed them in the first place. That's the kind of gap a skeptical justice, or a sharp opposing brief, can exploit at oral argument.
What to watch: Beck also weighed in on timing and politics. With the midterms approaching and the possibility that more states move on AR-15 bans before the Court rules, the justices may feel pressure to resolve the question sooner rather than let a patchwork of bans spread further. He also flagged that one of his own cases is approaching a fresh circuit split, which could give the Court another vehicle to take up AR-15 and magazine bans soon.
Also on the docket: The podcast's second half covered a loss for the Department of Justice in its suit over "gun-free zone" signage in Montgomery County, Maryland. The ruling could undercut the DOJ's broader Second Amendment Section litigation strategy. Separately, DOJ filed a new 2A suit against a California city charging would-be concealed-carry permit holders upwards of $2,000 — a fee gun-rights advocates argue functions as a backdoor ban on exercising the right.
The bottom line: Connecticut's AR-15 case hinges on whether old English carry and poaching laws can stand in for a modern possession ban — and Beck says they can't.
- Feb 19, 2026SCOTUS, Shooting Crack Second Amendment
- May 11, 2026SCOTUS Gun Cases Coming Soon
- Jun 25, 2026SCOTUS Kills Hawaii's Anti-Carry Default
- Aug 31, 2026SCOTUS Strikes Hawaii Gun-Free Default
- Oct 3, 2026Territory Court Guts Gun Rights
- Nov 16, 2026CT's Gun Ban History Challenged (this article)
- Phils Custom Handloads(Swartz Creek, MI)
- Gls Guns(Sumner, IA)
- J & L Gunsmithing(Chesapeake, VA)
- Oliver Firearms(Spartanburg, SC)
Loading comments...