Skip to main content
NEWS
4 min read

Fifth Circuit Backs Gun Sales

The Fifth Circuit ruled the Second Amendment protects firearm sales, not just ownership, vacating a lower court's dismissal of a dealer's constitutional challenge and sending the case back for further review.

Steve DuskettNovember 21, 2026
Article Info

Fifth Circuit Backs Gun Sales

Court DecisionDeveloping
Scope
JurisdictionFederal
Impactnational
Key Entities
Issuing courtU.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Defendant/appellantJeremiah Micah Deare
Concurring judgeJudge James Ho
Concurring judgeJudge Andrew Oldham
Dissenting judgeJudge Catharina Haynes
Legal Issues
  • Whether the Second Amendment's plain text covers commercial firearm sales
  • Whether federal FFL licensing requirements survive Bruen's historical tradition test
  • Whether prior precedent (United States v. Peterson) improperly extended registration-based reasoning to sales restrictions
What It Means
  • Establishes that the Second Amendment's text covers firearm sales, not just possession
  • Federal dealer-licensing requirements must now be justified under Bruen's historical-tradition test on remand
  • Does not invalidate existing FFL licensing or record-keeping laws
  • Creates a circuit-level precedent that could influence other challenges to federal gun-commerce regulations
  • Deare's case returns to district court for further constitutional review
Timeline
November 19, 2026Fifth Circuit issues ruling in United States v. Deare
Related Laws

Fifth Circuit Backs Gun Sales

A federal appeals court says the Second Amendment covers more than owning a gun — it covers buying and selling one too.

From The Boise Gun Club Handbook

A federal appeals court just ruled that the Second Amendment doesn't stop at your front door — it follows the gun all the way through the sale.

What happened: The Fifth Circuit ruled November 19 in United States v. Deare that the Second Amendment's text covers firearm sales, not just possession and carry. The three-judge panel vacated a lower court's rejection of a constitutional challenge to federal firearms-dealer licensing law and sent the case back to the Western District of Louisiana for another look.

"The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms," the court wrote in its published opinion. Even the federal government's own lawyers conceded that point during oral arguments — a concession that undercuts the broader argument that Congress can wall off gun commerce from constitutional scrutiny just by calling it "regulation."

The case behind it: Jeremiah Micah Deare was indicted in Louisiana for conspiring to deal firearms without a federal license and for false statements on dealer records, violating 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1). He challenged the licensing and record-keeping rules as unconstitutional. The district court disagreed, ruled the requirements were commercial regulation rather than a burden on the right to keep and bear arms, and let a jury convict him on all counts. He got 97 months.

The Fifth Circuit said that reasoning skipped a step. Citing its earlier ruling in Reese v. ATF, the court noted that the right to possess a firearm necessarily includes the right to get one in the first place. You can't exercise a right to a tool the government won't let you buy.

What the concurring judges said: Judge James Ho wrote separately to hammer the point home, comparing gun dealers to booksellers under the First Amendment — the government can't strip constitutional protection from an activity just because someone gets paid to help people exercise a right. Judge Andrew Oldham, joined by Ho, went further, arguing that a restriction on firearm sales burdens the buyer's rights as much as the seller's, and that under Bruen, the government now has to prove federal licensing fits the nation's historical tradition of gun regulation — not just assume it does. Oldham also took aim at the circuit's prior Peterson decision, arguing it wrongly treated licensing and registration schemes as automatically constitutional, though the court stopped short of overturning it.

Yes, but: Judge Catharina Haynes dissented, arguing the Constitution's text doesn't specifically mention sellers and that Deare hadn't proven the licensing law unconstitutional. She'd have upheld the conviction outright. The majority rejected that distinction between owning and selling.

What this doesn't do: The ruling doesn't strike down the FFL licensing system, doesn't erase record-keeping requirements, and doesn't give anyone a green light to deal guns without a license. Deare's case goes back to the district court, which now has to determine whether the specific licensing and record-keeping rules he was prosecuted under can survive historical scrutiny under Bruen — not whether they're automatically exempt because they're "commercial."

What to watch: How the Western District of Louisiana applies the historical-tradition test on remand will shape how far this principle extends — and whether other circuits start treating gun commerce as squarely within Second Amendment territory instead of a regulatory side door around it.

#
Was this article helpful?

Loading comments...