Mystic Arms and Supply

Mystic Arms & Supply operates as a residential firearms dealer licensed to handle federal transfers and sales in southeastern Connecticut. Located at 52 Sharon Rd in Mystic, they run by appointment only and focus on streamlined transactions with transparent pricing.

Firearm Transfers - Incoming transfers from other dealers or private sales - Self-service online portal to pre-fill Connecticut state paperwork before you arrive - Standard FFL transfer process with Connecticut DPS-67-C and DPS-3-C forms - Processing typically takes about 24 hours after the firearm arrives - You'll need: $25 (cash preferred), valid driver's license, and Connecticut pistol permit or military CAC to pick up

Used Gun Trades They actively buy used firearms. Here's their approach: send an email or call for a ballpark value. They use the Blue Book to price your gun fairly and show you the numbers upfront. No negotiation theater—they're buying to resell, so don't expect full retail, but you'll know what to expect.

Consignments You keep ownership until the gun sells. Consignment fees run 15-25% (no upfront costs). Once sold to a new buyer, you get paid. It's useful if you want access to more buyers than you could reach on your own.

Estate Gun Collections If you're settling an estate or liquidating a collection, they'll purchase the entire lot at once. They price each piece based on market, manufacturer, model, and condition. You get immediate payment instead of waiting for individual sales. They won't resell items for less than the agreed price—if a "close" offer comes in, they'll call you for approval first.

GunBroker Receiving Station Won an auction on GunBroker? Have it shipped to Mystic Arms. Here's the process:

• •GunBroker asks for your receiving dealer at checkout—select Mystic Arms & Supply in Mystic
• •The dealer receives an FFL request automatically; the seller gets Mystic Arms' FFL via email
• •If the seller doesn't respond, Mystic will send the FFL directly
• •Gun arrives and is processed (24 hours typical)
• •You pick it up with $25, driver's license, and Connecticut permit/military ID

• •Licensed FFL — Fully compliant with federal regulations for shipping ammunition and hazardous materials
• •Transparent Pricing — No surprises on trade-in values or consignment fees
• •Connecticut Compliant — Familiar with state-specific forms (DPS-67-C, DPS-3-C) and permit requirements
• •30-Day Return Window — If a defect appears after purchase, contact them within 30 days; defects covered, ordinary wear is not

They're straightforward about their policies: all sales are final unless defective. If you cancel before shipping, there's a 15% restocking fee. If you cancel after shipping, the sale stands.