Fagans Firearms
Fagans Firearms operates out of a historic building that started as Davenport's District #7 schoolhouse (built after 1865), then served as the IOOF Hall before becoming Lyn's Leisure Tyme Gun Shop for decades. Today it continues that tradition as a true mom-and-pop operation where community and serv...
Own Fagans Firearms?
01 // DETAILS
Business Details
Full description and what we offer
Fagans Firearms operates out of a historic building that started as Davenport's District #7 schoolhouse (built after 1865), then served as the IOOF Hall before becoming Lyn's Leisure Tyme Gun Shop for decades. Today it continues that tradition as a true mom-and-pop operation where community and service come first.
Modern Firearms - AR-15s and modern tactical rifles - Hunting rifles and shotguns - Handguns and carbines - Buy, sell, and trade on everything
Antique & Vintage Guns - Bolt actions and lever-action repeaters - Early American sporting and military firearms - Collectible handguns from manufacturers like Colt, Winchester, Remington, Henry, Sharps, Spencer, and Marlin - Constantly updating inventory
Ammo & Accessories - Full ammunition selection - Speed loaders, magazines, and more
Buck Knives - EDC, hunting, and outdoor blades - Partner brand featuring legendary Buck Knives craftsmanship since 1902
| Service | Details |
|---|---|
| Sourcing | Access to large network; can locate and deliver nearly any firearm within 72 hours |
| Appraisals | Full-service gun appraisals for auctions, personal collections, estates; considers type, rarity, provenance, condition |
| Consignments | Inspect, value, market, and sell your firearms at fair market value |
| FFL Transfers | Accept firearms and ammunition transfers; contact for pricing and process details |
| Estate Services | Specialized consulting for gun collections; can sell through their GunBroker page |
"We are able to provide competitive pricing based on our size, buying power, and large network of distributors."
Their strength is personalized service backed by real buying power. Call or email with what you're looking for—they'll find it. Free appraisals and consignment options make liquidating collections straightforward.
Reduced Hours as of January 2026: Thursday & Friday 10am-5pm, Saturday 9am-5pm. They've cut hours to focus on sourcing deeper inventory and better serving customers.
Fagans Firearms, LLC 15849 New York Highway 23, Davenport, NY 13750 (607) 278-4059 • (914) 400-9207 (text/call) [email protected]
Rear parking available. Browse their eBay and Guns International pages for additional listings.